Disengage to create
AI is not stealing your creativity. It's starving it.
Dorka Nagy-Józsa, Horizontal Thinking (2027)
Everyone is asking whether the machine will out-create them. Wrong question. Horizontal Thinking argues that creativity is the one thing AI damages by being helpful: it deletes the empty time in which a half-thought used to become yours. The fix is not a tool. It's calendar surgery.
The starving, not the theft
I'm the type who goes on a full-day bike ride when my calendar is completely full. Then, this spring, I caught myself mounting a remote control on my handlebars - voice mode in one ear, an agent on the other end - so I could keep coding while riding. The person who tells leadership teams to disengage, turning her last offline hours into one more workstation.
Will the machine out-create you? On volume, sure. But volume was never where your creative value lived. Before AI, a half-cooked thought had to sit with you for a day or two. That wasn't dead time. It collided with things only you carry - the client from 2019, your grandmother's kitchen, the pricing disaster everyone else forgot - and came back changed. Came back yours.
Now you type it into a prompt and get a polished answer in twelve seconds. “The idea never had time to become yours.” In 12 minutes, a new homepage; in 120 minutes, two new products. The speed is glorious, and I'm not giving it back. But the sitting got deleted.
AI is instant gratification for intellectual curiosity, and instant gratification is the enemy of deep creativity.
In teams really using these tools, output per person is up. Genuinely new anything? Ask when the last idea appeared that didn't arrive pre-polished from a model. Teams are shipping more than ever and originating less than ever.
| Theft | Starvation | |
|---|---|---|
| The question | Will the machine out-create me? | Did the idea ever have time to become mine? |
| Who does it | The machine | You. Voluntarily. |
| Defense | Build fences | Farm |
Filed under noise
Your brain does its most creative work when you're not trying to be creative. Researchers scanning brains during focused tasks noticed that whenever subjects stopped working and just sat there, an entire system of regions started firing, in sync. It was politely filed as noise - the brain idling between the important bits. Today it's called the Default Mode Network, the DMN.
The idling was the workshop.
The DMN switches on when you daydream, stare out of a window, or stand in the shower. In 2024, Bartoli and colleagues published direct brain measurements in the journal Brain that added the causal arrow: when they disrupted the DMN with electrical stimulation in a small group of patients, their ability to generate original ideas dropped significantly.
My reading, which goes beyond that one study: your brain needs empty time to create. Not the Instagram-scrolling kind: real, boring, nothing-is-happening empty - the exact resource modern work has engineered down to zero, and AI is now scraping out of the corners.
Rick Rubin's The Creative Act warns that if you chase creativity, it may not come. “AI is the ultimate chasing tool.” My own best ideas - the ones that became products, keynotes, business directions - were all born far from my desk, in the saddle, in hours my calendar filed under “nothing.” The problem you couldn't crack in six focused hours cracks itself in six unfocused minutes in the shower.
The workshop escape route
Roughly every other leader reaches for the same exit: “Fine, my personal boredom is gone, I accept that - but creativity at our place is a team sport. We ideate together. We have workshops.” I can hear the Post-it packs being ripped open from here.
Group creativity is a polite fiction. It has survived sixty years of contradicting evidence for one optical reason: a room full of people with sticky notes looks like innovation. But creativity is two previously unconnected frames colliding - Koestler's bisociation - and that collision happens in one head. Always in one head. One brain connects two distant thoughts faster than eight brains waiting for each other.
The evidence started at Yale in 1958, when Taylor and colleagues put real brainstorming groups against “nominal groups” - the same number of people working alone, ideas pooled afterward. The real groups lost: fewer ideas, fewer unique ideas, lower quality. In 1987 Diehl and Stroebe named the mechanisms:
- Production blockingOne person talks, five sit muted.
- Social loafingSomeone else is surely rowing.
- Evaluation apprehensionPeople self-censor their strangest ideas in front of colleagues - and the strangest ideas are where the new lives.
Nemeth showed in 2004 that even the sacred “no criticism” rule earns nothing. In some of the studies, individuals working alone produced twice as many ideas as the groups. Twice. And yet Paulus and colleagues found a solid majority of people convinced they generate more ideas in a group - the illusion of group productivity. The workshop isn't lying about being pleasant. Only about being creative.
One honest exception: parallel online ideation, everyone typing at once. It works - because it removed the room. Groups are genuinely good at buy-in, building on ideas and choosing between them. Generating the new was never on that list.
Generate alone, evaluate together.
Engineering the emptiness
There is no tool for this. (I know. I checked.) Convergent thinking hunts one solution to one problem - useful, but never where the new arrives. Divergent thinking lets the head run loose. Audit one day, alarm to pillow: how many minutes did you spend focusing on nothing? For most leaders I work with, it rounds to zero. Divergent mode shows up once a day, right before sleep.
Even the commute - forty minutes, twice a day, of staring out of a train window - was load-bearing. We deleted it and then wondered where the ideas went. The fix is calendar surgery, in four cuts.
Divergent sessions. Four twenty-minute blocks every day. Walk, run, drive, fold laundry - hands busy, head not. No phone, no podcast, and no forcing yourself to “think about nothing” either; that's just convergent mode in a costume.
Planned emptiness. Blocked in the calendar, named, defended. Not meditation. Just nothing. If it isn't scheduled, this century will eat it.
The 24-hour AI-impulse delay. When the next half-formed idea arrives, write it on paper instead of prompting. Sit on it for a day, then prompt away: the idea will already be yours, and the answer will be better because the question got better.
The machine's output is capped by the ripeness of what you bring it.
Guard your boredom. Treat it the way you treat sleep: you can skip it for a while, and you'll pay for it the same way. Every app, feed and assistant is bidding for your empty minutes.
And yes: the remote control came off the handlebars.
What to do on Monday
- Book the 4×20 today.Four twenty-minute divergent blocks into each day this week - walk, drive, fold the laundry. No phone, no podcast, no input. Just let your brain run.
- Cut one planned-emptiness block.Put it into next week's calendar and defend it like a client meeting. Not meditation. Nothing.
- Install the 24-hour delay.The next half-formed idea gets paper and one full day before it gets a prompt. Fight against your inner urge. Compare the morning version with the original - the difference is you.
- Flip one ideation ritual.Next time, everyone generates alone, in writing, first; the room is only for building and choosing. Count the ideas. Apologize to no sticky note.
- Audit your rigs.Find the one place where you were still unreachable, and check honestly whether you've wired it for work without ever deciding to. Unwire it.
The most productive thing you can do today is absolutely nothing. It's the one deliverable the machine can't draft for you.
In the book
This page draws on Chapter 8 (Disengage to Create) of Horizontal Thinking: Leadership after the end of the specialist era by Dorka Nagy-Józsa, PCC, published by Y2Y Ltd. on January 1, 2027. The book has fifteen chapters and two letters from the future, and every chapter ends with something you can actually do on Monday.
Dorka Nagy-Józsa is CEO of Y2Y Ltd., an ICF PCC coach and an international keynote speaker on AI and leadership.
Questions
Does AI kill creativity?
Not by out-creating you. In Horizontal Thinking, Dorka Nagy-Józsa argues that AI is not stealing your creativity, it's starving it: a half-formed idea used to sit with you for a day or two and collide with things only you carry. Now it goes into a prompt and comes back polished in seconds, before it ever had time to become yours.
What is the default mode network and why does it matter for creativity?
The default mode network (DMN) is a brain system that becomes active when you stop focusing - daydreaming, staring out of a window, standing in the shower. It was long dismissed as noise. In 2024, Bartoli and colleagues reported in the journal Brain that disrupting the DMN with electrical stimulation significantly reduced the originality of people's ideas. The book's conclusion: your brain needs real, empty time to create.
Are group brainstorming workshops good for new ideas?
Not for generating them. Since a 1958 Yale study by Taylor and colleagues, research has found that people working alone and pooling their ideas outperform brainstorming groups, because of production blocking, social loafing and evaluation apprehension (Diehl and Stroebe, 1987). Groups are good at building on ideas and choosing between them. The book's rule: generate alone, evaluate together.
How can leaders protect time for creative thinking?
The book prescribes four cuts: four twenty-minute divergent blocks a day with no input, a planned-emptiness block in the calendar defended like a client meeting, a 24-hour delay between a half-formed idea and the first prompt, and guarding boredom the way you guard sleep.
Where does the idea of disengage to create come from?
From Dorka Nagy-Józsa, PCC, in Chapter 8 (Disengage to Create) of Horizontal Thinking: Leadership after the end of the specialist era, published by Y2Y Ltd. on January 1, 2027.
Read the whole argument.
Horizontal Thinking is published on January 1, 2027. The Kindle edition is open for pre-order now; the paperback goes on sale on Amazon the same day.